{"id":84278,"date":"2016-12-12T12:00:16","date_gmt":"2016-12-12T12:00:16","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/?p=84278"},"modified":"2016-12-10T15:13:25","modified_gmt":"2016-12-10T15:13:25","slug":"the-rebels-of-aleppo-are-no-heroes","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/2016\/12\/the-rebels-of-aleppo-are-no-heroes\/","title":{"rendered":"The ‘Rebels’ of Aleppo Are No Heroes"},"content":{"rendered":"

We refer to them as \u2018rebels\u2019 \u2013 as if they were the Maquis fighting in the French resistance or Partisans freeing Yugoslavia from the Nazis or, indeed, the insurgents of Warsaw struggling for freedom from the German SS. Which they clearly are not.<\/em><\/p>\n

<\/a>

Jabhat al-Nusra fighters parading through Aleppo last year Getty<\/p><\/div>\n

8 Dec 2016 – <\/em>I\u2019ve just spent hours watching footage of the siege. The pictures are familiar: planes fall like vultures through the sky and buildings are blown apart, children are brought to hospitals covered in blood, bodies are buried in shallow graves, hospitals themselves are repeatedly bombed, entire districts of the city turned to rubble, civilians flee their homes amid burning buildings. Rescue workers tug at the living and the dead amid the wreckage of the city. America and Britain demand an end to the destruction but do nothing. And Russia cynically and cruelly allows the innocent to die. Readers will know exactly what I am describing.<\/p>\n

The Warsaw Uprising, of course, 1944, not 2016. The scenes are eerily familiar to all that other blood-soaked footage from Aleppo we\u2019ve been watching more recently \u2013 but, in one critical way, very different. For the fighters of the Home Army in Poland \u2013 \u2018rebels\u2019 against German occupation, patriots loyal to the Polish government in London \u2013 appear constantly in the old black-and-white film of the Warsaw Uprising. Their own military targets are attacked by their enemy. Civilians are seen queuing for weapons to fight alongside the insurgents.<\/p>\n

Not exactly what you see in the terrifying film from eastern Aleppo this past year, where not a single \u2018rebel\u2019 can be identified \u2013 save for carefully posed shots in their own propaganda productions \u2013 and where every target is a hospital or a civilian home. And anyone who believes the French nonsense about Aleppo becoming the \u201cworst massacre since World War Two\u201d should study the stunning films I\u2019ve been watching in the Polish Museum of the Warsaw Uprising.<\/p>\n

<\/a>

Insurgents fighting on the streets during the Warsaw Uprising (Getty) (Getty Images)<\/p><\/div>\n

In the first week, the Nazis and their allies murdered up to 40,000 civilians. The Warsaw Rising was to last for only 63 days, but the death toll was up to 200,000 \u2013 half the total deaths of the entire Syrian war, even by the dodgy statistics upon which journalists currently depend. Warsaw in 1944 was total war indeed \u2013 even if we forget later massacres of even greater bloodshed: the Korean War, the Vietnam War, the 1991 and 2003 Iraqi wars, the Afghan wars, the Algerian war of independence against the French with a minimum of a million dead, which the French appear to have forgotten. The \u201cworst massacre since World War Two\u201d indeed!<\/p>\n

But now a reminder of the tragedy of Warsaw. By mid-summer of 1944, Russian troops had smashed through the German armies in the east on their way to Berlin, and reached the eastern banks of the Vistula river opposite the very centre of Warsaw. Nazi troops had already begun to evacuate the city and retreat towards the Polish-German border. The Polish \u2018Home Army\u2019 of General Tadeusz \u2018Bor\u2019-Komorowski, with the full knowledge of the Allied-supported Polish government-in-exile in London, decided that the moment had come to liberate Warsaw from the Nazis \u2013 at 5pm on 1 August, 1944.<\/p>\n

It was a calculated, daring and disastrous decision. Komorowski wanted to strike when the Germans were retreating \u2013 but before the Russians could \u2018liberate\u2019 Warsaw themselves and impose a Communist government on the once independent Polish nation. Britain and France had declared war on Germany in 1939, after Hitler attacked Poland \u2013 but they were powerless to help. Besides, Churchill and Stalin had already agreed that Poland would fall under Soviet \u2018influence\u2019 in post-war Europe.<\/p>\n

The Germans meanwhile brought in SS reinforcements and, on Hitler\u2019s specific orders, razed the entire city of Warsaw to the ground while the Russians watched from the other side of the Vistula \u2013 and did nothing. They were quite happy to allow the Nazis to crush the 50,000 armed nationalist Poles of the Home Army \u2013 leaving Warsaw to be \u2018freed\u2019 by the Russians in January 1945 and a Communist government imposed on the survivors.<\/p>\n

This is a necessarily truncated and simplified version of those terrible moments of history. The British and Americans deliberately delayed air drops of arms and medicine to the Poles in Warsaw and even refused to send the fully trained Polish Parachute Brigade to help them. RAF crews did volunteer to fly from Brindisi to Warsaw but were shot at by Russian as well as German artillery. An escaped British POW, RAF Lieutenant John Ward, actually joined the Home Army, the \u2018Armia Krajowa\u2019 (AK), fighting in the Rising and sending 64 reports of the battle to The Times<\/em> in London. Other foreigners, including Ukrainians, even Azerbaijanis, fought alongside the Poles, as well as Jewish survivors of the Warsaw Ghetto rising of 1943.<\/p>\n

<\/a>

Members of al Qaeda’s branch in Syria. The group has now rebranded in an attempt to give the impression it’s no longer connected to al Qaeda.
Mike Segar\/Reuters<\/p><\/div>\n

So back once more to Aleppo. No-one doubts that foreigners are fighting alongside Jabhat al-Nusra\/Al-Qaida and the Salafist Ahrar al-Sham and other groups around the city. But, oddly, that\u2019s not what we call them. We refer to them as \u2018rebels\u2019 \u2013 as if they were the Maquis fighting in the French resistance or Partisans freeing Yugoslavia from the Nazis or, indeed, the insurgents of Warsaw struggling for freedom from the German SS. Which they clearly are not. And while we know that the \u2018rebels\u2019 of eastern Aleppo have died fighting bravely, we also know that they have executed their internal enemies, slit the throats of their prisoners and that \u2013 well, since Jabhat al-Nusra is al-Qaida (and has since changed its name yet again) \u2013 they have flown passenger aircraft into very tall buildings in New York.<\/p>\n

Which the Polish resistance would not dream of doing. Indeed, in the footage shot by four named \u2018war photographers\u2019 for the Home Army\u2019s commander \u2013 their films were actually shown at a Warsaw cinema during the Rising \u2013 you can see captured German officers and men surrendering to the Poles, handing over their weapons and then being fed \u2013 and set to work building barricades for the defenders of Warsaw. The film subtitles even comment on the surprise of the German forces that they were not executed \u2013 as Poles were murdered at the hands of the Nazis.<\/p>\n

But back to the terrifying website and Facebook pictures that we still see from eastern Aleppo. Why do we not see the defending fighters, as we do on the Warsaw films? Why are we not told their political allegiance, as we most assuredly are on the Warsaw footage? Why do we not see \u2018rebel\u2019 military hardware \u2013 as well as civilian targets \u2013 being hit by artillery and air attack as we do on the Polish newsreels? Or civilians lining up for weapons to help the \u2018rebels\u2019 defend eastern Aleppo \u2013 as Polish civilians, prepared to defend their city, were filmed in Warsaw?<\/p>\n

No, this does not mean that the pictures of wounded and dead children in eastern Aleppo are fake. Nor does it mean that the Syrian army or the Hizballah or the Iranians or Iraqi Shiites are playing by the rules of war. In the Syrian conflict, there are no rules \u2013 except those made up on the spur of the moment for tactical military reasons \u2013 and there are no \u2018good guys\u2019 in civil wars. The battle of east Aleppo is vile and brutal. The Syrian military cannot \u2013 and does not \u2013 pretend that it has not killed civilians. Although, until recently, civilian casualties of artillery shells on western Aleppo fired by the \u2018rebels\u2019 \u2013 so constantly given that blessed anonymity by us in the press \u2013 have been almost totally ignored.<\/p>\n

My colleague Patrick Cockburn has expressed his own deep unease at the coverage of the Aleppo siege. For months, Western reporters have failed to state the obvious: that they cannot send their dispatches from \u2018rebel\u2019 areas because the \u2018rebels\u2019 would slit their throats open \u2013 or hand them over to other \u2018rebels\u2019 who would. And thus the \u2018rebels\u2019 have been tuned out of the story except for that one amorphous description. And the more anonymous they become, the braver they appear \u2013 fighters whose predecessors fought the Nazis in the Second World War rather than foreign-paid and armed opponents of the Syrian regime. And, by the same token, what better way of painting the besiegers of eastern Aleppo as descendants of the SS?<\/p>\n

If we could call Saddam the \u2018Hitler of Baghdad\u2019 and Milosevic the \u2018Butcher of Bosnia\u2019 and Nasser the \u2018Mussolini of the Nile\u2019 (as Eden actually did call him), then World War II goes on forever. Take a trip to Warsaw today, however, and you\u2019ll quickly learn that the Poles are a deeply betrayed people, and perhaps \u2013 constantly divided by three neighbouring powers (Austro-Hungary, Germany and Russia) as the Kurds are divided by four neighbouring powers (Syria, Iraq, Iran and Turkey) \u2013 they were born to be betrayed. But their struggle shows up the Aleppo battle in a very different light from that in which we are currently portraying it.<\/p>\n

So if you want to make parallels between Syria and the Second World War, for heaven\u2019s sake spot the difference. Civilians are always heroes, in Warsaw or Syria. So were the fighters of Warsaw. But are the \u2018rebels\u2019 of Aleppo heroes?<\/p>\n

______________________________________<\/p>\n

\"\"<\/a>Robert Fisk is the multi-award winning Middle East correspondent of <\/em>The Independent, based in Beirut. He has lived in the Arab world for more than 40 years, covering Lebanon, five Israeli invasions, the Iran-Iraq war, the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan, the Algerian civil war, Saddam Hussein\u2019s invasion of Kuwait, the Bosnian and Kosovo wars, the American invasion and occupation of Iraq and the 2011 Arab revolutions. Occasionally describing himself as an \u2018Ottoman correspondent\u2019 because of the huge area he covers, Fisk joined <\/em>The Independent in 1989. He has written best-selling books on the Middle East, including <\/em>Pity the Nation and<\/em> The Great War for Civilisation. He was born in Kent in 1946 and gained his BA in English and Classics at Lancaster University. He holds a Ph.D. in politics from Trinity College, Dublin. <\/em><\/p>\n

Go to Original \u2013 independent.co.uk<\/a><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"

We refer to them as \u2018rebels\u2019 \u2013 as if they were the Maquis fighting in the French resistance or Partisans freeing Yugoslavia from the Nazis or, indeed, the insurgents of Warsaw struggling for freedom from the German SS. Which they clearly are not. We know that they have executed their internal enemies, slit the throats of their prisoners and that \u2013 well, since Jabhat al-Nusra is al-Qaida (and has since changed its name yet again) \u2013 they have flown passenger aircraft into very tall buildings in New York.<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":4,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"closed","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[204],"tags":[],"class_list":["post-84278","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","category-syria-in-context"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/84278","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/4"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=84278"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/84278\/revisions"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=84278"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=84278"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.transcend.org\/tms\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=84278"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}