The Fractured Chorus: Jewish Elites, Gaza, and the Weight of Selective Silence

PALESTINE ISRAEL GAZA GENOCIDE, 6 Oct 2025

Diran Noubar – TRANSCEND Media Service

4 Oct 2025 – In the shadow of the ongoing attack on Gaza, which has claimed tens of thousands of lives since October 2023, a narrative has emerged: the “shameful silence” of Jewish elites across global industries. Critics argue that prominent figures—bound by shared heritage, fear of backlash, or institutional pressures—have largely withheld condemnation of Israel’s military actions in Gaza, allowing atrocities to unfold without the moral urgency their platforms demand.  This perceived muteness isn’t absolute; voices of dissent have pierced the quietude, often at great personal cost. Yet, the asymmetry—where support for Israel flows freely but critique of its Gaza campaign trickles out—raises uncomfortable questions about complicity.

Music: Harmonies of Dissent Amid Orchestrated Quiet

The music world, a realm of raw emotion and public anthems, has seen Jewish artists navigate Gaza with a mix of bold solidarity and conspicuous restraint. On one hand, a wave of Yiddish musicians has channeled historical Jewish suffering into laments for Gaza’s plight. In September 2025, artists like those featured in the collection Lider mit Palestine released songs portraying Israel as the “evildoer,” invoking klezmer traditions to mourn Palestinian losses in a language scarred by the Holocaust.  Similarly, hundreds of Israeli musicians, including singer Chava Alberstein and jazz bassist Avishai Cohen, signed an August 2025 petition demanding an end to the “horrific” war, citing Judaism’s ethical imperatives against unchecked violence.  These acts of defiance have sparked backlash: signatories faced event cancellations and boycotts, forcing artists to choose between domestic vilification and international isolation.

Contrast this with the silence from global Jewish music icons. Figures like Bob Dylan or contemporary stars such as Adam Levine (Maroon 5) have offered no public commentary on Gaza’s humanitarian crisis, even as non-Jewish peers like Roger Waters and Annie Lennox amplify calls for Palestinian rights.  This reticence echoes broader critiques: Jewish musicians, embedded in pro-Israel networks, risk career sabotage by speaking out, perpetuating a “conspiracy of silence” that mutes empathy for Gaza’s 2 million displaced.  As one Yiddish performer noted, “Blood is red”—a universal truth too often obscured by tribal loyalties.

Cinema: Spotlights on Complicity in Tinseltown

Hollywood, with its cadre of Jewish powerhouses, exemplifies the tension between artistic freedom and geopolitical allegiance. The industry’s response to Gaza has fractured along familiar lines: vocal opposition met with swift counter-mobilization. In September 2025, over 4,500 filmmakers, including Jewish actors like Mark Ruffalo and directors such as the Coen brothers’ collaborators, pledged to boycott Israeli state-funded projects, decrying the war as a “genocide” and Hollywood’s “silence, racism, and complicity.”   This surge marked a cultural shift, with pro-Palestine stances shedding their taboo status, as evidenced by Javier Bardem’s unapologetic UN speech.

Yet, a parallel silence—or active defense—from other Jewish elites underscores the divide. Stars like Scarlett Johansson and Gal Gadot, both outspoken Israel supporters, have avoided critiquing Gaza operations, focusing instead on hostage releases and Israeli resilience.  In response to the boycott pledge, over 1,200 entertainment leaders, including Jewish actors Liev Schreiber and Debra Messing, issued an open letter rejecting it as “censorship and collective punishment,” framing artistic boycotts as antisemitic echoes of history’s darkest chapters.    Critics lambast this as deflection: by equating antiwar advocacy with bigotry, these voices shield Israel’s actions while muting Gaza’s documented horrors.  The result? A cinematic echo chamber where Palestinian narratives remain sidelined, even as Israel’s own filmmakers face domestic censorship for similar critiques.

Politics: Partisan Fault Lines and Fading Unanimity

In the political arena, Jewish American leaders have grappled with Gaza amid eroding consensus. Once a monolith of pro-Israel solidarity, U.S. Jewish opinion has splintered: a September 2025 survey revealed only 31% support the war, with growing distrust in both Israeli and American policies.  Progressive voices like Rep. Jamie Raskin and Sen. Bernie Sanders (Jewish) have condemned civilian casualties and urged ceasefires, aligning with broader Democratic shifts where just 27% deem Israel’s actions justified.

However, establishment figures such as Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and AIPAC-backed donors have maintained a more guarded tone, prioritizing aid to Israel over unequivocal Gaza critiques. This “deep sense of trauma” from October 7 fuels a defensive posture, but it’s increasingly viewed as moral evasion.  In August 2025, over 100 U.S. Jewish leaders signed a letter imploring Israel to allow more aid into Gaza, signaling a tipping point where silence yields to urgency.   Yet, as Peter Beinart argues in Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza, this reticence has eroded Judaism’s ethical core, leaving elites vulnerable to accusations of abetting “genocide.”

Literature: Pages of Reckoning and Unwritten Chapters

Literature, ever the conscience of society, has birthed poignant responses from Jewish authors, though not without controversy. Judith Butler’s 2023 call to “stand up against genocide” galvanized intellectuals, framing silence as complicity in Israel’s assault.  Peter Beinart’s 2025 book Being Jewish After the Destruction of Gaza demands a “new Jewish narrative,” critiquing Zionism’s postwar distortions and urging empathy for Palestinian dispossession.  Other voices, like those in Jewish Authors Critical of Zionism, including Ilan Pappé and Avi Shlaim, dissect Israel’s founding myths through Gaza’s lens, fostering “empathy” via novels like Dorit Rabinyan’s All the Rivers.

Still, viral lists branding authors like Jonathan Franzen or Nicole Krauss as “Zionists” for their reticence highlight the chill effect.  While non-Jewish writers like Sally Rooney boycott Israeli publishers, Jewish literary elites often demur, their unwritten op-eds a testament to institutional fears.  As Beinart posits, this selective muteness risks a “moral cost,” alienating younger Jews and amplifying global antisemitism accusations as shields against accountability.

Postwar Shadows: Justice for Netanyahu and Reckoning for the Silent

As of September 30, 2025, glimmers of resolution flicker: President Trump and Prime Minister Netanyahu have endorsed a 21-point U.S.-brokered ceasefire plan, envisioning a demilitarized Gaza under non-Hamas administration, with pathways to Palestinian statehood. Hamas’ review could halt the bloodshed, but Netanyahu’s fate looms large. Facing ICC arrest warrants for alleged war crimes, the Israeli leader—accused of prolonging the conflict to evade corruption trials—may confront domestic trials or coalition collapse if the deal falters.   A postwar Israel could see him ousted, branded a war criminal in global annals.

For Jewish elites, the aftermath promises introspection over indictment. Those who stayed silent may face reputational erosion: boycotts, lost endorsements, and generational schisms, as young Jews (per surveys) increasingly reject uncritical Zionism.  Vocal critics like Beinart predict a “reckoning,” where silence is retroactively judged as enabling destruction, fracturing alliances and birthing a more pluralistic Jewish identity.  Yet, in a Trump-era realignment, pro-Israel stalwarts might pivot to reconstruction narratives, mitigating fallout. Ultimately, Gaza’s scars will test not just Netanyahu’s impunity, but the elites’ capacity for atonement—lest their quietude echo eternally.

This conflict defies binaries; Jewish voices span condemnation to defense, shaped by grief and geopolitics. True progress demands amplifying the silenced, on all sides, toward a shared humanity.

_____________________________________________

Diran Noubar, an Italian-Armenian born in France, has lived in 11 countries until he moved to Armenia. He is a world-renowned, critically-acclaimed documentary filmmaker and war reporter. Starting in the early 2000’s in New York City, Diran produced and directed over 20 full-length documentary films. He is also a singer/songwriter and guitarist in his own band and runs a nonprofit charity organization, wearemenia.org.

JOIN THE BDS-BOYCOTT, DIVESTMENT, SANCTIONS CAMPAIGN TO PROTEST THE ISRAELI BARBARIC GENOCIDE OF PALESTINIANS IN GAZA.

DON'T BUY PRODUCTS WHOSE BARCODE STARTS WITH 729, WHICH INDICATES THAT IT IS PRODUCED IN ISRAEL. DO YOUR PART! MAKE A DIFFERENCE!

7 2 9: BOYCOTT FOR JUSTICE!

This article originally appeared on Transcend Media Service (TMS) on 6 Oct 2025.

Anticopyright: Editorials and articles originated on TMS may be freely reprinted, disseminated, translated and used as background material, provided an acknowledgement and link to the source, TMS: The Fractured Chorus: Jewish Elites, Gaza, and the Weight of Selective Silence, is included. Thank you.

If you enjoyed this article, please donate to TMS to join the growing list of TMS Supporters.

Share this article: email mastodon facebook 🔗 copy link

This work is licensed under a CC BY-NC 4.0 License.

There are no comments so far.