A Light in Algerian Darkness: Mourad Dhina 6 Feb 2007

EDITORIAL, 6 Feb 2012

#203 | Johan Galtung

Syria is horrible.  Assad should step down immediately, a coalition government should come into being, and a thousand mediators should talk with the many parties, maybe with a federation in view.

But Algeria is even worse.  A quarter million killed after democratic elections were denied them, with Western consent, more than twenty years ago.

Why no Algerian Spring?  Maybe because the darkness is too deep, too complete, too repressive.  Why no protest from the West?  Maybe because the Algerian government did all the West wanted, access to oil and gas, to bases, and a promise of possible recognition of Israel.  Syria did none of this, none of that.

Mourad Dhina was a totally nonviolent light in that darkness.  He was arrested and may be extradited to Algeria.  His case is very well stated in the public letter below to the French Prime Minister.

On Sunday, 15 January 2012, French minister of foreign affairs, Alain Juppé, met Aung San Suu Kyi at her residence in Rangoon and decorated her with the insignia of Commander of the National Order of the Legion of Honor.

The day after, January 16th, the men of the French minister of interior, Claud Guéant, arrested in Paris the Algerian political figure and human rights defender Mourad Dhina.

So similar conflicts, so similar resistants but very different French treatment.

M. Le Premier Ministre: Le Dialogue est la voie!


24 January 2012

M. François Fillon, Prime Minister

Hôtel de Matignon 57, rue de Varenne

75700 Paris – FRANCE

 Re: Arrest and detention of Alkarama executive director, Dr Mourad Dhina

 Mr Prime Minister,

 We, the undersigned international and national human rights organizations, call on you not to extradite Dr Mourad Dhina, executive director of Alkarama – a Swiss foundation working on human rights in the Arab world. French police arrested Dr Dhina on Monday 16 January 2012, at the request of the Algerian authorities.

 In addition to being Alkarama’s executive director, Dr Dhina is also a founding member of Rachad, a peaceful political association that is legally registered in France and that seeks democratic change in Algeria.

 Dr Dhina had been attending a meeting of Rachad in Paris when police arrested him at Paris-Orly airport as he was about to fly back to Geneva, where he resides. Since then, French authorities have stated that they are detaining Dr Dhina at the request of the Algerian authorities, who are seeking his extradition to Algeria for prosecution on charges that he belonged to an armed terrorist group in Switzerland in the 1990s.

 On Tuesday 17 January, the President of the Paris Court of Appeal confirmed Dr Dhina’s detention in view of his potential extradition to Algeria, and that Algerian authorities would have 30 days to present the case for his extradition.

 Dr Dhina has played a key role in exposing human rights violations in the Arab world through his work at Alkarama. In addition, his political activities have been carried out in lawful exercise of his freedom of expression and association, as guaranteed under international law. Dr Dhina had travelled freely to France on numerous past occasions. We therefore fear that the request by the Algerian authorities may be motivated by a desire to muzzle him because of his political activities with Rachad and his activities as a human rights defender with Alkarama.

 We further fear that Dr Dhina would be at risk of torture and ill-treatment if he were sent back to Algeria, given the documented use of torture by the Algerian authorities – most recently referred to by the Committee against Torture during its review of Algeria in 2008. This would be contrary to France’s obligations under articles 3 of the European Convention on Human Rights and the United Nations Convention against Torture. We also are concerned that Algeria’s record of convicting suspects in manifestly unfair trials in cases involving allegations of terrorism would put Dr Dhina at risk of a conviction and a prison term on the basis of a trial that falls far short of international norms for a fair trial violating the prohibition of non-refoulement.

 Given the key role France has played in the establishment of an international system for the promotion and protection of human rights, and the emphasis it places on the respect of human rights domestically, we hope that you will be able to assist us in protecting Dr Dhina’s rights by ensuring that he is not extradited. Furthermore, if there is no credible evidence that he has committed any crimes that are recognized as such under international standards, we urge French authorities to release him immediately. France must uphold its international obligations with respect to human rights and avoid possible complicity in efforts by Algerian authorities to stifle opposition and human rights activities by Algerians in exile.

 Yours sincerely,



Algeria Watch

Cairo Institute for Human Rights Studies (CIHRS)

Centre Libanais pour les Droits de l’Homme (CLDH)

Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Network (EUROMED)

International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH)

Front Line Defenders

International Commission of Jurists (ICJ)

Ligue des droits de l’Homme

World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT)

This article originally appeared on Transcend Media Service (TMS) on 6 Feb 2012.

Anticopyright: Editorials and articles originated on TMS may be freely reprinted, disseminated, translated and used as background material, provided an acknowledgement and link to the source, TMS: A Light in Algerian Darkness: Mourad Dhina 6 Feb 2007, is included. Thank you.

If you enjoyed this article, please donate to TMS to join the growing list of TMS Supporters.

Share this article:

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a CC BY-NC 4.0 License.

3 Responses to “A Light in Algerian Darkness: Mourad Dhina 6 Feb 2007”

  1. Dietrich Fischer says:

    Dear Johan,
    Thank you for your courage and compassion to speak out against this horrible injustice!
    I hope the French government will listen and reconsider.
    Best wishes, Dietrich

  2. Nouh says:

    It is very strange how came the French authority can arrest Dr Dhena with charge that could be deported to Algerian services DRS to make him case that calling for destabilization of regime and against constitution law and finally to be sentenced.
    I think the French services must think twice before to came that steep it could enter France against human right constitutions.
    So we want the French court authority to be fair and proceed with what is legal and right justice to be independent and just not some other alternatives to be consider for instance Sarkozy election to guaranty election campaign by Algerian services DRS

  3. Middle Easterner says:

    While the West certainly uses double standards, your depiction of Syria includes several factual mistakes:

    1. Syria actually had a detente with parts of the West – and with France in particular – between 2007 and 2011. It did some of what France asked for (including Syrian support for French forces in Iraq) and in exchange Assad was welcomed by Sarkozy in a festive ceremony Paris.

    2. Assad’s Syria, like Algeria, supported the Arab Peace Initiative, thus giving the same “promise of possible recognition of Israel”.

    Sometimes the different policies of the West are not merely the result of the extent to which a country cooperated with the west but also of circumstances and social chance (luck).