Bradley Manning and the Appalling Silence of Gay, Inc.


Gilad Atzmon – TRANSCEND Media Service

I have never published materials concerning gay issues, but I decide to publish the following CounterPunch’s article because it touches some interesting spots within the context of  marginal politics. In the next few days I will try to extend the discourse and discuss the links between LGBT, Palestinian Solidarity and the Jewish progressive voice.  

By Andy Thayer – CounterPunch

In Failing to Support Bradley Manning, Gay NGOs Betray Their Own Mission Statements and Fail to Promote an Inclusive Justice Agenda

One of the signature traits of LGBT subculture in the United States is its adoration of celebrity.  If a well-known person voices the most milk-toast notion that gays are human beings, let alone deserving of legal equality, banner headlines in the gay press are guaranteed.  If the celebrity comes out as gay, even more effusive coverage is given.

Any number of fading stars and starlets, and non-entities on the make, from Lady Gaga to Chaz Bono to Ricky Martin, have mined the LGBT community to support their careers. Our community’s eager rush to embrace just about any celebrity who deigns to notice our existence is emblematic of our lack of self-esteem, our internalized homophobia.

So why is it that all of the big gay non-profits, from the National Gay & Lesbian Task Force (NGLTF) to the Human Rights Campaign (HRC) – “Gay Inc.” – have failed to utter a word of support for Private Bradley Manning, let alone really campaign for him?  He’s gay, has moderately high name recognition, and unlike any number of air-head celebrities, he’s actually done something to support social justice, rather than mined charitable causes for personal fame and fortune.

Manning’s contributions to human rights have been recounted frequently enough to require only a brief recitation here.  He exposed U.S. war crimes in Iraq [2] [3] [4] and Afghanistan.  His exposure of the corruption of the oligarchy in Tunisia helped kick off the ‘Arab Spring,’ toppling U.S.-supported dictators around the region.

He exposed the Obama administration’s support for the 2009 military coup in Honduras [2], the first successful Latin American coup in a decade and half, that led to a wave of violence against LGBTs and others, making it the murder capital of the world.

The list goes on.  No less an authority than Daniel Ellsberg, exposer of the Vietnam War era Pentagon Papers, has said Bradley Manning “is a hero in my heart. He did what he should have done.”

Besides the Honduran angle – 89 LGBTs murdered over three and a half years in a country of less than 8 million, including leading activists like Walter Trochez and Erick Martinez Avila – there are other LGBT angles that NGLTF and HRC could have highlighted.  The sexually humiliating torture that Manning received, stripped naked in a cell for days on end, ordered by no less than a two-star general – was tinged in homophobia, and yet where were the protests from the gay human rights groups? Not even a token press release.

If a homophobe had so much as broken Chaz Bono’s finger nail, rest assured that assured GLAAD, NGLTF and HRC would have been on the case.  But why the silence about Manning?

It’s political cowardice.  A failure to take on “difficult” political subjects, particularly when doing so might bite the (Democratic Party) hands that feed them.  This same failure of political courage is why gay NGOs routinely fail to take on powerful anti-gay forces like the Mormon Church and Catholic Church leaderships, frequently allied with powerful local and national Democratic politicians, even when these religious leaders are pushing discriminatory referenda like Prop 8.  Even when such failure spells defeat for gay rights (unlike back in the day when Harvey Milk, et al., took on Anita Bryant and the Briggs Amendment, and won).

It’s why they take a pass on opposing pink-washing of apartheid in Israel, when they’re not directly participating in it, while the Obama administration funds Israel to the tune of a record $3 billion a year.  And while they may whine about budget cuts that hit AIDS funding and other social services, you won’t hear them denouncing the Obama administration’s military spending (equal to the rest of the world’s combined), let alone its wars from Yemen to North Africa to Afghanistan that drive it.

Bradley Manning’s great sin, in the view of the gay NGOs, was in exposing not just the depravity of the Bush administration’s foreign policy, but Barack Obama’s as well.  The fact that it is Obama’s Justice Department that is prosecuting Manning makes it so much the worse. That his Justice Department has prosecuted more whistle-blowers than the combined total of every President who preceded him is a particular embarrassment.

Since the late 1970s, gay NGOs have effectively acted as an adjunct of the Democratic Party, which is why they were “shocked, shocked” when Bill Clinton gave us “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” and the Defense of Marriage Act.  One would never know from Gay Inc’s pronouncements that the two biggest legislative attacks on gay rights of the last century were undertaken and vigorously defended by Democrats.

At the end of the day, Gay Inc. sees its source of jobs in Democratic administrations, its executive directorships with six-figure salaries, its charity balls and other celebrity-driven hoopla as more important than gay rights.  And when individual LGBTs like Bradley Manning through their own courage expose the human rights fakery of Democratic politicians, they can twist in the wind.

Just as much of the anti-war movement was “anti-war” only when a Republican president was leading the wars, much of the gay movement is pro-gay only when it’s non-Democrats who are anti-gay.

The Obama administration is leading the attack on the most important whistle-blower of our era, a gay man whose persecution was tinged with homophobia.  The Honduran coup, which it supported and Manning helped expose, is murdering LGBTs and others at a horrific rate.  While Gay Inc. keeps quiet, while lapping up favors from its political allies, we must not.


Andy Thayer is a co-founder of the Chicago-based Gay Liberation Network.  He can be reached at

Go to Original –

Share this article:

DISCLAIMER: The statements, views and opinions expressed in pieces republished here are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of TMS. In accordance with title 17 U.S.C. section 107, this material is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. TMS has no affiliation whatsoever with the originator of this article nor is TMS endorsed or sponsored by the originator. “GO TO ORIGINAL” links are provided as a convenience to our readers and allow for verification of authenticity. However, as originating pages are often updated by their originating host sites, the versions posted may not match the versions our readers view when clicking the “GO TO ORIGINAL” links. This site contains copyrighted material the use of which has not always been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. We are making such material available in our efforts to advance understanding of environmental, political, human rights, economic, democracy, scientific, and social justice issues, etc. We believe this constitutes a ‘fair use’ of any such copyrighted material as provided for in section 107 of the US Copyright Law. In accordance with Title 17 U.S.C. Section 107, the material on this site is distributed without profit to those who have expressed a prior interest in receiving the included information for research and educational purposes. For more information go to: If you wish to use copyrighted material from this site for purposes of your own that go beyond ‘fair use’, you must obtain permission from the copyright owner.

3 Responses to “Bradley Manning and the Appalling Silence of Gay, Inc.”

  1. I liked this sentence: “Just as much of the anti-war movement was “anti-war” only when a Republican president was leading the wars, much of the gay movement is pro-gay only when it’s non-Democrats who are anti-gay.” It reminds me of a political Forum to discuss the occupation of Afghanista. It was full of Left-Wingers, who kept shouting protestations against Cameron and his Right-Wing policies for occupying Afghanistan. However, they all conveniently forget it was a Labour Government who invadad the country. The Left also never criticized Russia when they invaded and occupied Afghanistan. Even worse, they never mentioned about Russia invading and occupying for half century, Poland, Lithuania, Romania, Hungary, Yugoslavia, Armenia, Estonia, Bulgaria, Ukraine, Latvia, Georgia, etc,.

    There is, however, another, more serious issue in this article, the contents in the tenth paragraph: “…..while the Obama administration funds Israel to the tune of a record $3 billion a year.”. This wrong !!!! USA only helps American military manufacturers. The $3 billion are for Israel to buy USA made weapons, bombs, air-fighters, etc, etc. Just as British Prime Minister offered financial assistance to India. Cameron was NOT helping Indian (for them to have wars and die, is this help????; he was only helping the British Arms Trade.

    In the same sentence we read “… won’t hear them denouncing the Obama administration’s military spending (equal to the rest of the world’s combined),” it is wrong to suggest money was wasted, squandered. All it happens is that money changes hands, as everybody has to make a living. Buildings have to be destroyed so that construction companies have lucrative contracts. People have to die, so that bomb sales continue and the manufacturer can pay his staff. Manufacturers of soldiers uniforms need soldiers to die and be replaced by new soldiers, so that their business doesn’t suffer. (dead soldiers are buried in their uniforms so you continually need new ones).

    We also have the very lucrative Refugee Industry, worth billions. All those tents, portable beds, bathrooms and kitchens. Without creating mass exodus, politicians cannot promote this industry.

    Don’t forget that politicians are committed – are obliged – to help those who help them. These are not Peace lovers, students, musicians, intellectuals, waiters, chefs, nurses, etc. These people are weapon manufacturers, air-fighter makers, nuclear submarine constructors, oil giants, Banks, etc, etc.

  2. David Moore says:

    Greetings from your friend in Pennsylvania! What has happened to Bradley Manning is an injustice beyond words. He should be released from confinement, and the charges should be summarily dismissed with the apologies of the court-martial. He exposed to the press information that demonstrates the social and legal injustice perpetrated by both the Bush and Obama administrations. My group, Marriage Equality for Pennsylvania, is not afraid to take on any political party that commits atrocities. Thank you for posting this story, and framing it as you have. This small part of “Gay, Inc.” agrees with you.

    Check us on facebook:

    Again my thanks,
    David E. Moore
    Marriage Equality for PA, Founder

  3. Stacey Gray says:

    The problem, as many of us see it, is that gay or straight, republican or democrat, well known or not, morally well intentioned or otherwise, what Manning is accused of is treason. While it may be old fashioned, many of us believe that giving aid and comfort to the enemy, of bringing embarrassment upon the nation, of risking the security of agents and operatives, of damaging the intelligence network thereby threatening national security, especially while in uniform, is a crime worthy of severe punishment.

    While obviously cause célèbre, this episode is not a cause to celebrate. In a world where our very existence depends upon mainstreaming our community, appearing to align with such “un-American” activity is certainly more damaging to, than supportive of, our cause.

    While an end to aggression and hostility and fostering world peace are certainly admirable objectives, as a community our focus must be upon the human rights and civil rights that will allow us to live in peace here in the United States.