The Thinker: Neighbors Like These
TRANSCEND MEMBERS, 9 Aug 2010
Dr. Zarni – TRANSCEND Media Service
Once again India has rolled out the red carpet for Burma’s aging despot Than Shwe, whose sleep has reportedly been disrupted by his deep-seated fears of being hauled to The Hague for his alleged crimes against humanity.
And yet leading Indian newspapers such as The Hindu and the Times of India have come out in full support of the New Delhi ruling elite’s pathetic embrace of a prospective war criminal, rationalizing and popularizing India’s uncivilized Burma policy, devoid of both modern humanism and ancient wisdom.
Gandhi once famously — or infamously — remarked that western civilization would be “a nice idea” (in response to a fan’s question “What do you think of Western civilization?”)
Were a similar question posed about today’s Indian civilization, the Burmese public would be likely to come up with the same response: “Indian civilization would be a nice idea.”
They will indeed “look west” and witness that India has reached a new “civilizational” low with its greedy resources grab in Burma and ugly “realpolitik”.
Despite India’s anglophone elite of around 200 million — many of whom are Oxbridge and Ivy League alumni — the India of today embodies neither the liberal ideals of the European Enlightenment nor the Spiritual Enlightenment of Gotama Buddha or Gotama the Enlightened.
The fanciful label “the world’s largest democracy” which Indian elites often tout when it suits them means little for the Burmese. India behaves no differently from today’s authoritarian states in Asia or Africa.
(Regarding India’s reputation of being the world’s largest democracy, it would be intriguing to survey the opinions of the two thirds of the country’s 1 billion population who have been eternally condemned to abject poverty and social and political exclusion, thanks to Indian State policies and practices.)
To belabor the obvious, India as a nation-state is as greedy, exploitative and destructive (towards other societies as well as its own laboring classes) in its pursuit of its internal elite’s interests as, say, China or Russia — neither of which pretends to be other than authoritarian.
Indeed when it comes to narrowly defined national commercial and strategic interests, no differences can be detected between Oxbridge-educated political leaders such as Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, Chinese politburo members and former Soviet KGB operatives.
India runs its foreign policy as if governing a nation-state were no different from managing a brothel—a purely business transaction (euphemistically referred to in political discourse as “realpolitik”), without any human value or vision worthy of a civilization.
India’s conduct today reminds me of the “politics-is-not-about-ethics-or-compassion” reply I received from the President of Singapore S. R. Nathan, when he was Singapore’s ambassador to Washington almost two decades ago.
As Nathan bluntly put it, “running a country is not like running a church,” implying that ethics, compassion and values don’t belong to statecraft.
Nathan was responding to a question I posed during a “questions and answers” session after a lecture he delivered at the University of Wisconsin in Madison: How can your Singaporean government justify selling the Burmese military junta an unknown quantity of arms immediately after the massacre of several thousand unarmed Burmese protesters, including university students, monks, schoolchildren, housewives and even civil servants in 1988?
It hardly surprised the audience in the room that the then Singaporean ambassador to Washington would be so forthcoming about his government’s world-famous immorality.
For the highly polished Cambridge- and Harvard-schooled ruling elite of this city-state neither practices nor believes in any ideal other than the profit-motive.
Casinos, amusement parks, strip-malls, money-laundering and arms deals seem to mean a great deal more to them than such “alien” ideals as “a representative government.”
But the world’s “largest democracy” pimping its civilizational wisdom for gas and oil, as well as out of its fear and loathing of China?
With neighbors like these the Burmese public can only expect their “hell on earth” to get worse and worse in the years to come.
__________________________
Dr. Zarni is a research fellow on Burma at the London School of Economics and a visiting senior fellow at the Institute of Security and International Studies at Chulalongkorn University.
This article originally appeared on Transcend Media Service (TMS) on 9 Aug 2010.
Anticopyright: Editorials and articles originated on TMS may be freely reprinted, disseminated, translated and used as background material, provided an acknowledgement and link to the source, TMS: The Thinker: Neighbors Like These, is included. Thank you.
If you enjoyed this article, please donate to TMS to join the growing list of TMS Supporters.
This work is licensed under a CC BY-NC 4.0 License.